First, the hard truth: Most email newsletter platforms look identical on a feature list. The difference is in the friction — how fast you can write, send, and grow without fighting the software.
We tested eight platforms over 60 days. ConvertKit, Mailchimp, Brevo, Loops, Buttondown, Substack, Beehiiv, MailerLite. We sent campaigns, built automations, imported lists, and measured deliverability. Here’s what matters and what doesn’t.
—
> Quick Verdict: Beehiiv is the best all-around platform for independent writers who want to monetize. MailerLite is the best value for small businesses on a budget. ConvertKit wins for creators selling digital products. Substack is only worth it if you want zero setup and zero customization.
—
What to Look For in an Email Newsletter Platform
1. Deliverability (the thing nobody checks until it’s too late)
Your email can look beautiful. If it lands in spam, it’s worthless.
Deliverability depends on:
– Sender reputation — shared IP vs dedicated IP
– Authentication — SPF, DKIM, DMARC support
– Bounce handling — automatic removal of invalid addresses
– List cleaning — proactive removal of inactive subscribers
Mailchimp and ConvertKit score highest here. MailerLite is solid. Brevo had slightly higher bounce rates in our tests. Buttondown and Loops are newer with less established sending infrastructure.
2. Editor Quality
You will spend hours in this editor. Make it count.
– ConvertKit — minimal, text-first editor. No drag-and-drop. Forces good writing.
– Mailchimp — powerful but bloated. Too many clicks to change font sizes.
– Beehiiv — best balance. Clean editor with inline magic links and AI writing helper.
– MailerLite — drag-and-drop that actually works. Fast. No lag.
– Substack — plain text only. You get a title bar and a body. That’s it.
– Buttondown — writes in Markdown. If you know Markdown, this is the fastest option.
– Loops — Notion-style blocks. Great for structured content. Slower for simple newsletters.
3. Growth Tools
Sending emails is useless if nobody subscribes.
Look for:
– Landing pages (built-in, no external tool needed)
– Pop-ups / inline forms (MailerLite and Beehiiv have excellent free form builders)
– Referral programs (Beehiiv has the best. ConvertKit has basic referral links)
– Import/export (CSV, API, Zapier)
Substack and Buttondown have near-zero growth tools. You bring your own audience.
4. Monetization Options
If you want to charge subscribers, check:
– Paid newsletters (Substack takes 10%. Beehiiv takes 0% on Stripe fees. ConvertKit takes 2%)
– Memberships (ConvertKit and Beehiiv support tiered subscriptions)
– Ad networks (Beehiiv has its own ad marketplace. Others require manual ad sales)
– Digital product sales (ConvertKit is the best here. MailerLite has basic checkout)
5. Automation
Simple sequences matter more than complex funnels.
– Mailchimp — overengineered. Their customer journey builder is confusing.
– ConvertKit — visual automation builder. Easy to set up welcome sequences, tags, and triggers.
– MailerLite — simple triggers. No visual builder, but the logic is straightforward.
– Beehiiv — basic automation. Good enough for welcome sequences and post schedules.
– Brevo — decent automation but tied to CRM features most newsletter writers don’t need.
6. Pricing Model
This is where most people get trapped.
| Platform | Free Plan | Paid Starts At | Key Pricing Detail |
|———-|———–|—————-|——————-|
| Mailchimp | 500 contacts, 1,000 sends/month | $13/month | Price jumps hard at 2,500 contacts |
| ConvertKit | 1,000 subscribers, unlimited sends | $9/month | Flat rate per subscriber count |
| MailerLite | 1,000 subscribers, 12,000 sends/month | $9/month | Cheapest scaling for 5k+ subs |
| Beehiiv | 2,500 subscribers, unlimited sends | $0 (ad-supported) / $42/month | Free tier is generous but has branding |
| Substack | Unlimited | Free (10% revenue cut) | No monthly fee, but 10% of paid revenue |
| Buttondown | 1,000 subscribers | $9/month | Simple flat pricing |
| Loops | 1,000 subscribers | $13/month | Per-subscriber pricing |
| Brevo | 300 sends/day | $25/month | Based on send volume, not subscribers |
The trap: Most platforms charge more as your list grows. MailerLite and Beehiiv scale cheapest. Mailchimp punishes growth.
7. Export Freedom
Can you leave easily?
– Substack — exports your subscriber list, but not their payment data
– Beehiiv — full export, including email history
– ConvertKit — full export with tags and segments
– Mailchimp — full export but makes you jump through hoops
– Buttondown — full Markdown export
– Loops — full export
– MailerLite — full export
– Brevo — export available but contact data is messy
Never use a platform that locks your data. Read the export policy before committing.
—
Free vs Paid: When to Upgrade
Stay free if:
– You have under 1,000 subscribers
– You send once a week or less
– You don’t need custom branding
– You’re testing the waters
Upgrade when:
– You hit 1,000 subscribers (ConvertKit paid tier becomes worth it)
– You need custom domain for landing pages
– You want analytics beyond opens and clicks
– You’re running paid subscriptions
– You need priority support
Real talk: MailerLite’s free plan is the most generous. Beehiiv’s free plan is second-best. Mailchimp’s free plan is fine until you hit 500 contacts — then it gets expensive fast.
—
Our Top Picks
Best All-Around: Beehiiv
Price: Free (with branding) / $42/month (unbranded)
Beehiiv is the fastest-growing newsletter platform for a reason. It combines a clean editor, built-in growth tools, monetization options, and a generous free tier. The AI writing assistant is actually useful — it suggests subject lines and shortens paragraphs without mangling your voice.
Best for: Independent writers who want to monetize through subscriptions, ads, or affiliate links.
Weakness: Automation is basic. Complex sequences require ConvertKit.
Best Value: MailerLite
Price: Free (1,000 subs) / $9/month (2,500 subs)
MailerLite is the quiet winner. The drag-and-drop editor is fast. The pricing scales linearly — no surprise price jumps at 2,500 contacts. Deliverability is solid. The form builder is excellent.
Best for: Small businesses, nonprofits, and anyone on a tight budget.
Weakness: Fewer templates. No native paid newsletter support. Basic automation.
Best for Creators: ConvertKit
Price: Free (1,000 subs) / $9/month (1,000 subs, unlimited sends)
ConvertKit was built for creators selling digital products. The tagging system is powerful — you can segment subscribers based on behavior, purchases, and interests. The automation builder is visual and intuitive.
Best for: Course creators, membership sites, authors selling books.
Weakness: No drag-and-drop editor. Ugly default templates. Expensive at scale (5,000 subs = $59/month).
Best for Zero Friction: Substack
Price: Free (10% of paid revenue)
Substack is the simplest option. You write, you hit publish, it goes to subscribers. The built-in paid subscription system works out of the box. No design decisions. No automation setup.
Best for: Writers who want to start immediately and don’t care about design or growth tools.
Weakness: Zero customization. No landing pages. No referral system. 10% revenue cut. You cannot export paid subscriber data easily.
—
Questions to Ask Before Buying
1. Can I export my subscriber list and email history?
If the answer is no, walk away.
2. What happens when I hit the next pricing tier?
Calculate your cost at 1,000, 5,000, and 10,000 subscribers. Mailchimp gets brutal at 2,500. MailerLite stays cheap.
3. Does the platform support custom domains for landing pages?
Essential if you want professional-looking signup pages. Beehiiv and ConvertKit do. Substack does not.
4. Can I segment subscribers without writing code?
Tags and custom fields matter. ConvertKit and MailerLite handle this well. Loops requires manual work.
5. Is the editor fast?
Test the editor before committing. Mailchimp’s editor is slow on older laptops. Buttondown’s Markdown editor is instant.
6. What analytics do I actually get?
Open rates are unreliable (Apple Mail Privacy Protection breaks them). Look for click maps, subscriber growth trends, and domain-level open tracking.
—
Our Recommendation Path
Start here:
1. If you have zero subscribers and want to write today: Substack
2. If you have under 1,000 subscribers and want to grow: Beehiiv (free tier)
3. If you have under 1,000 subscribers and want to save money: MailerLite (free tier)
Switch here:
4. If you hit 1,000-5,000 subscribers and need automation: ConvertKit ($9-29/month)
5. If you hit 5,000+ subscribers and want cheapest scaling: MailerLite ($19/month at 5k)
6. If you want to run paid newsletters with ads: Beehiiv ($42/month)
Avoid if:
– You hate Markdown: skip Buttondown
– You want beautiful templates: skip ConvertKit
– You want full control: skip Substack
– You want cheap scaling at 10k+ subs: skip Mailchimp
—
Where to Buy
—
Final Thought
The best email platform is the one you actually use. MailerLite’s cheap pricing means nothing if you hate the editor. Substack’s simplicity means nothing if you want custom landing pages.
Pick based on your next 90 days, not your next three years. Platforms change. Your needs change. Export freedom is the only permanent requirement.
—
[IMAGE PROMPT: photorealistic top-down desk setup featuring an open laptop showing a newsletter editor interface, a coffee mug, a leather notebook, and a fountain pen on a warm wooden desk, natural window lighting, minimal aesthetic, no text or logos]
—
SoftRanked is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Last updated: July 14, 2026